“Clear” data temporarily enjoined from sale, but not yet safe
According to news reports today, Verified Identity Pass, Inc., (“VIP”) which operated the defunct Clear traveler registration scheme, has been temporarily enjoined by a Federal court from selling or transferring to any third party any data about its (former) customers.
That doesn’t mean that the personal data about “VIP” travelers — including fingerprints, iris scans, and data about their passage through “Clear” lanes at airports — is safe. The injunction is only preliminary, and was issued in a case in which Clear customers have sued for refunds. More importantly, VIP is not (yet) bankrupt and hasn’t yet been sold, although since the shutdown of the Clear service it has no revenue and no way to avoid bankruptcy except through a sale of all or part of its business or assets.
The terms of service and privacy policy for the Clear program contained an explicit provision authorizing the sale or transfer of customer data to another company providing a similar service, as part of a sale of the entire line of business. And if VIP goes bankrupt, the bankruptcy court would still be required to auction the personal data to the highest bidder, unless in the meantime Congress enacts new privacy protection for personal data in bankruptcy cases.
I think a good case could be made contesting “ownership” of the personal data. The persons contesting, though, would have to file in the bankruptcy case, though. Perhaps a good means for Proving A Point, but a lot of work for an individual.
Congressmen don’t want Registered Traveler data deleted (by Michael Fabey, Travel Weekly, August 26, 2009)
Pingback: Papers, Please! » Blog Archive » Congress, investors won’t let “Trusted Traveler” die